To You the Missing One
The King of Knights who first answers your call is clad in dark iron and has an armor as cold as her face.
The soot of Fuyuki is still fresh on your knuckles, and for a second you forget to breathe. She tried to kill you. She just tried to kill you. She answered your call and she contracted with you so she must be here to help but she tried to kill you. You can't afford to pass up an ally, you really can't, but your hands are shaking just at the sight of you. She tried to kill you. She tried to kill you.
"When you kneel before your enemy, I shall have your head." She says, and you can tell, she means it. "Until then, you can trust me."
So, this is it. King Arthur’s true face.
"Ah, King Arthur." Emiya says the name with something nostalgic off his tongue. You know next to nothing about his past. He's not some grand hero, he's not in history books. You know nothing of who he used to be, and he refuses to talk about it. Still, sometimes, he lets a few things slip. "Of course she'd come here. She's always cared too much. She wouldn't leave Chaldea to fight on its own."
...
Artoria.
Caring.
"Don't mind me. I am a woman who feels not of my follower's death, nor my people's suffering." That's what she's told you, verbatim. This doesn't... match up. How does Emiya even know Artoria in the first place?
(He doesn't answer, of course, and you sure aren't going to ask Artoria about it.)
You kind of forget about it until London rolls up. Artoria is a strong fighter, but she dislikes sticking around after battles. And, let's be honest, you're not eager to get to know her either.
And then you meet Mordred.
Mordred’s description of Artoria does match up, this time. King Arthur, the emotionless, inhuman king. That's how I got people to follow me in the rebellion. They boast. Yet it’s... still a little weird. Mordred speak of their father with anger, but also affection. Admiration. Like it’s a good thing. Artoria isn’t as bad as your chaotic evil servants, that’s true, (hello Carmilla) but she’s still... a tyrant? Like... not very good?
Why... is there admiration here? Why is Mordred, the knight of rebellion, the one praising her?
The next servant you summon is a Lancer. She wears Artoria's face, and is dressed in the same curse, and the memory of lightning is still fresh in your mind, so you brace yourself for the worst.
But it doesn't happen.
Nothing happens at all. Lancer is scarcely here outside of battles. Stranger still, she's actively avoiding Saber. But even when you run into her, she's... not here is the best way you can describe her. She’s in Chaldea physically, for sure, but... she doesn’t seem to realize she’s awake at all. Still, in her rare moments of clarity, she’s surprisingly... soft? She’s kind to Mordred, to Mordred’s own confusing.
It’s weird. It’s weird. Who is Artoria Pendragon?
Camelot. Camelot. Camelot and its zealous knights. Camelot and it’s divine king.
Why are they following her? You don’t understand. It can’t be out of ideals. It’s out of guilt, you can tell, you can tell, (way too many of your owns are plagued by guilt.) But why? What is so admirable about Artoria Pendragon to warrant such loyalty?
You meet the Lion King. That goddess in a human coat. She means well. That’s what hits you about her. She means well. She means well but she is so, so far removed from human thinking, that the only way you can oppose her is with fists and blades.
Who is Artoria Pendragon? The one who feels nothing or the one who loves too much? Who is Artoria Pendragon?
You're missing something. You're missing a crucial piece of the Artoria puzzle. Something that tie all these people together, a common truth from which they were all born.
Artoria Lancer- the one with lights dancing in her eyes, the one of lions rather than dragons- comes to Chaldea. The king one step removed from godhood. She’s dignified and prideful, though in a less burning way than Saber. It’s hard getting close to her, but while the other Lancer is just plain not here and Saber makes a point to keep a hierarchy between the two of you, this Lancer just... doesn’t seem to get human relationships very much. You keep your eyes off her face and she asks why. You don’t answer.
(Your side still hurts where her lance pierced you.)
With Artoria Lancer comes Bedivere, Lancelot, Gawain, Tristan. They all have their own stories, too. She fought until the end. She never blamed me. I didn’t do enough. I didn’t understand her. They all have their stories and their guilts, and all, save Bedivere, maybe, all, you can feel their yearning. They want their king. They want to make amends. They want to talk.
Who is Artoria Pendragon? Who is it who ruled over them?
And then one day Saber Lily comes to Chaldea, and, ah. You get it now.
Lily is kind. Lily is easily excited. Lily is full of hope and energy. Lily is, somehow, the same person as all these others you have summoned.
Who is Artoria Pendragon? Who is Artoria Pendragon? Someone between Lily and Lartoria. Someone between Lartoria and Lalter. Someone parallel to Salter. Who is Artoria Pendragon? Who is Artoria Pendragon?
There is someone, at this crossroad, in the liminal space between their existence.
You stand before the summoning circle. Her knights are yearning. They can’t mourn. Ghosts can’t just mourn. If they’re alive, why isn’t she? Why isn’t she in Chaldea too?
You see her face everywhere. Nero, who wished to be loved as much as her. Okita, who wished to fight until the end like Bedivere told you she did. Jeanne, who was adored just as strongly as she was.
Who is Artoria Pendragon? Who is the King of the Britons?
The summoning circle stays silent. There is no one here.
TungstenCat: This is great. The short, punchy sentences work perfectly here. And thank you for putting in words what I could never quite pin down about Lancer Alter, the ephemerality of her.
ConfusedCanadian: Oh well done this was a joy to read!
Lolk (AmberGimlet): The idea of the "ideal" artoria being a point that she always only orbits for each person who has met her is exquisite. Amazing ending.
Puffins_Incorporated: I’ve been reading several of your fics in a row and everything you write manages to knock me the fuck out how do you do it??? How did you pin down the og Artoria Pendragon when she’s not even in the fic?
pearypie: I read this back in 2020 and it's been in the back of my mind ever since. The original Artoria being a complete non-entity in FGO has inexplicably always felt very /right/ to me, and you've managed to put into words exactly why. Peak haunting the narrative, and it hits even harder post-LB6. Thank you for sharing!